news & views

/ A Guide to Commercial Leases for Tied Pub Tenants

share
A tied pub lease is an agreement between a ‘pub-owning business’ (POB) and a publican. As a tenant, the publican will want to ensure that they secure favourable lease terms, particularly as the lease will have a significant impact on their ability to run a sustainable and profitable business.

In this guide, we provide the critical information tied pub tenants need before entering into a commercial lease. 

Tied Pub vs Freeholds


A ‘tied pub’ is a public house that is owned by a pub business (the POB)  and leased to a tenant. This type of tenancy agreement enables the publican (tenant) to run the establishment but requires that they purchase some or all of their drink stock from the landlord (the POB). 

In contrast, a free-of-tie pub (often called a “Freehouse”)  allows the operator tenant as the publican (owner) to purchase any beer and drink stock from any supplier - this means a wider range of choice and better prices for the publican than being tied.

While tied pubs can represent a profitable business opportunity for publicans, the terms of the commercial lease can have a substantial impact on the subsequent success of the business.

The Pubs Code: Understanding Your Rights


The Pubs Code etc. Regulations 2016 (amended in 2022) apply to pub-owning businesses with more than 500 pubs and are designed to protect tied pub tenants. Under The Pubs Code, POBs have certain duties they must fulfil, such as:

  • Dealing with tenants fairly

  • Reassessing rents every five years (if a review hasn’t taken place) 

  • Provision of necessary information before entering into or renewing a lease

  • Advising tenants to seek professional advice


In essence, The Pubs Code aims to ensure that tied pub tenants are not worse off than freehold publicans. While not every tied pub tenant will be protected by the Code, it will be applicable if the landlord owns more than 500 pubs. If you’re considering entering into a commercial lease with a POB that is subject to The Pubs Code, it’s important to understand your rights under the Code and ensure that they are upheld.

The Pubs Code also provides a tied pub tenant in various circumstances with a statutory right to go free of tie and purchase their drink stocks from any supplier. However, the process can be lengthy and costly, and engaging the right professionals to  advise is essential (see below) 

Tied Pub Tenancies: Key Considerations


Before signing a tied pub tenancy, it’s essential to do your due diligence and seek legal advice. By doing so, you can secure the best possible lease terms and reduce the risk of future landlord-tenant disputes, such as checking whether the lease contains a workable break clause.

Using a solicitor when leasing commercial property is often the best way to safeguard your interests.

With this in mind, take a look at some of the key considerations tenants should take into account before agreeing to a commercial lease for a tied pub:

Extent of the Tie


Becoming a tenant of a tied pub means you’ll be required to purchase some or all of your stock from the landlord (or their nominated supplier). However, the extent of the tie can vary depending on the terms of your agreement, for example:

Partial Tie


Under a partial tie, you will need to purchase some of the drink stocked in the pub (such as draft beer) from the landlord or their nominated supplier.

Full Tie


A full tie agreement means you’ll need to purchase all of the stocked drink from the POB or their nominated supplier.

Insurance Liability


Having adequate insurance coverage is essential for any business and your commercial lease should set out which party is liable for taking out insurance. Remember – different types of insurance are required and/or advisable, so don’t assume one party will necessarily be liable for all types of insurance coverage.

Price Lists and Trading Terms


The POB should supply an up-to-date price list (including discounts) that informs the tenant of the cost of purchasing stock. In addition, relevant trading terms should be made clear so that the tenant can plan their future business activities and forecast potential profit and loss.

Flow Monitoring Equipment


In tied pubs, it’s not unusual for flow monitoring equipment to be installed so that POBs can analyse the volume of dispensed drink in relation to reported sales. It’s fairly standard for POBs to be responsible for the cost of installing and maintaining this equipment but tenants are often liable for the cost of electricity to run the system. 

Premises Licence and Condition


Pubs are licensed premises and, as such, you’ll want to make sure that the site has the requisite license(s) to trade. Crucially, it’s important to find out if any conditions have been applied to the license, as these could affect your ability to trade.

Schedules of Condition


A Schedule of Condition sets out the condition of a premises at a particular point in time, such as at the start of a tenancy. If future liability for maintenance or repairs is called into question, the Schedule of Condition can be relied upon to determine what condition the property was in at the start of the tenancy and can, therefore, protect your interest and prevent future disputes.

Rental Price


Before signing a commercial lease, you’ll want to review the proposed rental amount and determine whether it’s affordable for your business and a good deal in the current market. 

Repairs and Dilapidations


The cost of maintenance and repairs can be significant, so you’ll need to know which party is responsible for these costs before you sign a commercial lease.

This is often governed by dilapidations clauses, which define tenant obligations. Understanding dilapidations clauses in a commercial lease is essential to avoid unexpected liabilities.

Option to Go ‘Free of Tie’


The option to go ‘free of tie’ essentially means that you will be free of the obligation to purchase some or all of your stock from the POB or its nominated supplier. Understandably, POBs typically want their tenants to remain ‘tied’ as it generates more income for their business.

so it is also important to understand whether the commercial lease contains a break clause if you need a route out of the arrangement altogether.

Get Expert Legal Advice on Tied Pub Tenancies from RLS Law


As highlighted above, there are numerous aspects to consider before signing a commercial lease for a tied pub. By seeking expert legal advice now, you can protect your interests and ensure that your rights are upheld. Moreover, it can help you to negotiate more favourable lease terms from the outset. 

From pubs and bars to restaurants, RLS Law specialises in leases for the leisure industry.

For an initial consultation, contact our team by sending us a message here.

Other RLS guides:
Our clients
Prev Arrow
Next Arrow