news & views

/ Break Clauses: What Are They & How Do They Work?

share
A break clause is a legally binding provision in a commercial lease that allows either the property owner or the business renting the space to end their agreement early. The lease will set out whether you can trigger this right on a specific fixed date or on a rolling basis.

If you wish to terminate your tenancy before the contractual term expires, understanding how these provisions work is essential to avoid costly property disputes.

Negotiating Your Exit Strategy 


During the Heads of Terms stage, you have the opportunity to negotiate how and when the lease may be terminated early. Depending on the bargaining power of both sides, the right to leave early can be: 

  • Tenant-only: Only the renting business has the right to terminate early.

  • Landlord-only: The property owner can end the agreement, typically because they plan to sell or redevelop the site.

  • Mutual: Both sides have the right to trigger the early exit.


Whether you’re negotiating lease terms for office and industrial units or retail and leisure premises, break rights can have a major impact on flexibility later on.

When Are You Allowed to Use a Break Clause?


To use a break clause successfully, you must stick with the exact dates written in your agreement. Usually, leases require written notice three to six months before the break date. If you get this wrong by even 24 hours, the notice may be invalid.   The lease will also include a clause dealing with how and where the notice needs to be served for it to be valid.   

Any failure to comply with the conditions in the break clause will invalidate the break and you remain liable under the lease, including for rent and other outgoings, until the term expires. Similar issues can arise during business lease renewals, where strict deadlines and procedural requirements also need to be followed carefully.

These financial obligations can also shift over time depending on how rent is periodically reassessed under the lease (rent reviews), making it important to understand the wider cost implications before deciding whether to exit.

It is also worth noting how joint tenancies work. If multiple people or companies are named on the lease, all joint tenants must typically exercise the break right together, unless the contract specifically states otherwise.

Can You Change Your Mind?


Once you serve an early break notice, you cannot unilaterally withdraw it. If you change your mind and want to stay, the property owner has to agree. Even if both sides agree to ignore the notice, the parties will need to enter into a new lease taking effect immediately after the existing lease ends. This is often approached in a similar way to the lease renewal process, where terms are renegotiated for continued occupation.

Key Conditions and Where People Go Wrong


Ending a tenancy early is almost never just a matter of dropping a letter in the post. Property owners tend to add very specific hurdles you need to clear first. The courts also interpret these requirements very strictly. If you fail to comply with even a minor requirement, your attempt to exercise the break clause may fail.

This is why it is so important to understand the key terms properly before signing a commercial lease.

Getting the Notice Right


Your contract tells you exactly how to deliver the paperwork, and you cannot deviate from it. If the lease requires hand delivery to a registered office, sending an email will not suffice. You also need to make sure the right person actually gets it. For instance, if the building was sold recently, the notice must be served on the new owner, not the former one.  A solicitor would usually do a Land Registry search to see who the current owner of the building is.

Payments and Hidden Arrears


The lease may state that all rent, service charges, and insurance must be fully up to date for the break to be effective. Make sure you clear all outstanding bills, even if you happen to be arguing over a particular charge at the time.  Beware not to apportion the sums up to the break date and pay the entire sums due as this could invalidate the break.

You must also watch out for late payment interest. Even if the owner never actively chased you for interest on a late rent payment from three years ago, that interest is still technically due and may also be a condition of the break. 

Rent paid upfront catches a lot of people out. See the Supreme Court decision in Marks and Spencer plc v BNP Paribas Securities Services Trust Company (Jersey) Ltd, for example. The Supreme Court held that commercial tenants do not automatically recover rent paid in advance for the time after they leave, unless the lease specifically states the advance sums will be refunded.

Handing Back an Empty Property


Many leases require the tenant to give ‘vacant possession’. In other words, you must remove all persons, possessions and interests from the premises. That includes staff, sub-tenants, and all your chattels. If you leave behind bags of rubbish, an old desk, or even forget to take down some internal walls, the landlord may argue that vacant possession has not been given. That alone may invalidate the exercise of the break clause.

This often overlaps with dilapidations obligations, where tenants may need to carry out works and reinstate the property before they can exit cleanly.

A clear schedule of condition at the start of the lease can also help reduce disputes over the state in which the premises must be handed back.

Why Do These Clauses Cause So Many Disputes?


These provisions frequently give rise to litigation because significant sums may be at stake. Property owners naturally want to keep their rental income flowing and are keen to avoid vacant premises. Because of this, they may scrutinise the notice and the tenant’s compliance carefully in order to identify any basis for challenge.

The smallest mistake can completely derail your plans to leave. Take the Sirhowy Investments Ltd v Henderson case, for instance. A tenant attempted to exercise its break right but failed because it had not repaired a small hole in a fence. That oversight meant the lease continued, and the tenant incurred a liability of £70,000.

What Tenants and Landlords Must Check


A party wishing to exercise the break clause needs to instruct solicitors to carefully review the break clause and all the conditions attached to it, well in advance of the deadline for serving the break notice. 

The solicitor will do all the necessary due diligence and prepare and serve the notice in accordance with the terms of the lease. They will also advise on the conditions attached to the break and what needs to be done to comply with them.

This is one of the reasons why using a solicitor when leasing commercial property can be so important. Missing a technical requirement could have costly consequences.

RLS Law: Commercial Property Specialists


Having the option to terminate a lease early can be valuable, but the relevant requirements can be difficult to navigate. If you make a mistake, you could remain liable for years.

At RLS Law, our London-based commercial property solicitors advise businesses on complex lease negotiations and break notices every day. Whether you are a tenant or a landlord, we can protect your position and guide you. 

Contact us today. 

Additional Resources:


Our clients
Prev Arrow
Next Arrow